The Erosion Control Blogs

The Blogger

Kaspersen, Janice

More from this blogger

view all

Erosion Control Editor's Blog

  • RSS
  • Save
  • Print
  • Email
Tuesday, January 24, 2012 7:55 AM

The Seed Question

By: Kaspersen, Janice Comments

What to do after a wildfire—particularly, whether to apply seed—has been a debated by the Forest Service, Burned Area Emergency Response (BAER) teams, and others. In an effort to establish vegetation quickly and anchor the soil before the rainy season hits, the obvious choice in many cases has been to seed the burned area as quickly as possible. Planting native species is also believed to limit the opportunity for invasive plants to take get a foothold.

In some areas, however, hydromulching without seed has been successfully used instead, often with berms and other sediment control measures on hillsides to prevent soil loss.

Recent studies by the Agricultural Research Service shed more light on when seeding is most effective, how it’s best done, and when to let nature take its course instead. The success of postfire reseeding was studied at four burn sites in Oregon covering about 300,000 acres overall. As this ARS article describes, native species including desert wheatgrass, western wheatgrass, basin wildrye, Snake River wheatgrass, Sandberg bluegrass, Siberian wheatgrass, yarrow, and blue flax were planted using various methods, with and without irrigation and weeding.

One conclusion: At least in the Oregon environment, weeding and watering didn’t make much difference. (A different experiment, reported in the same article, showed good success using hydrogels to establish native grasses planted during the dry season in arid environments.)

And, although native plants such as sagebrush burned during the fires at the Oregon sites, other fast-growing native plants established themselves more readily than invasive plants like cheatgrass. “Taken together, these findings suggest that it could be time to revamp traditional approaches to postfire rangeland restoration, starting with assessments of whether reseeding is even necessary,” the article states.

Upcoming Forester University Webinars

January 26th, 2012
5 Steps to Creating a Successful Public Outreach Campaign
Change starts with people. Whether your focus is stormwater pollution, energy conservation, pavement restoration, or recycling, a successful public outreach campaign resonates with your target audience and leads to long-lasting behavior change. Join Erica Hooper of SGA to explore a proven 5-step approach to crafting a successful outreach campaign based on real-world examples of the good, the bad, and the ugly. Read more…

February 2nd, 2012
Advanced Stormwater Treatment: Dissolved Pollutants
How effective are your stormwater treatments in capturing dissolved loads? With an average of 45% of the phosphorus load and up to 50% of the metal load transported through treatment practices to receiving waters in dissolved form, advanced treatment is imperative. Join Andrew Erickson to explore cost-effective, field-tested methods to capture stormwater dissolved pollutants and optimize stormwater treatment performance. We’ll explore several field applications and data demonstrating significant improvements in dissolved pollutant fraction capture. Read More...

What Do You Think?

Julie Etra, WBS Inc, MS, CPESC

Wednesday, January 25, 2012

Excellent comments and I agree every fire and every site is different and design must be site specific, including choice of mulch etc. However desert wheatgrass and Siberian wheatgrass are certainly not native.

Rich Casale

Wednesday, January 25, 2012

Interesting article on the "Seed question" following wildfire. Be very careful here especially with drawing conclusions from different research in different states. From my 38 years as a field natural resource restoration specialist and certified professional erosion and sediment control specialist I have found restoration of soil, slopes, and landscapes following fire to very site specific. In almost every case I do NOT recommend seeding either native or non-native grasses following wildfire for a variety of reasons. In cases where I have recommended seeding I have recommended fast growing sterile annual cereal grains to protect against soil erosion and trap sediment immediately surrounding homes, waterways, roads in rural or urban built-up areas and never in wildland areas. An understanding of hydrophobicity, soil type, crusting/ash, fire occurrence, and vegetative type burned is imperative before making any soil and land disturbance following wildfire. In most cases I recommend that landowners not become their own worst enemy by doing the wrong thing just because they feel that they need to do something. The same holds true if the property is owned by a municipality, state or federal government. More often than not, doing nothing is the preferred response and alternative. Understanding natural processes in play and considering site conditions and natural response is the first step to doing the right thing following fire. Being too quick to respond, especially by disrupting the soil and/or seeding can significantly slow down regeneration, especially the plants that will do more for soil stability than a "smoke screen" of grass. Restoration following wildfire is more about understanding site conditions, soil, natural drainage patterns,affect of increased and/or accelerated runoff & sediment management as well as understanding the watershed where the wildfire has occurred. Let's not let emergency seeding be our first thought and response following fire. It may be the absolutely wrong thing to do, and worse yet, end up giving a false sense of security.
Rich Casale, CPESC #3, District Conservationist, USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service, Santa Cruz County, CA

Post a Comment

Note from the Editor: The content that appears in our "Comments" section is supplied to us by outside, third-party readers and organizations and  does not necessarily reflect the view of our staff or Forester Media—in fact, we may not agree with it—and we do not endorse, warrant, or otherwise take responsibility for any content supplied by third parties that appear on our website. “All comments are subject to approval

CAPTCHA Validation
CAPTCHA
Code: